So, I did a ton of research. Lot's of google searches. Lots of YouTube videos. Lots of Pinterest-ing packing lists. I wanted to make sure that I didn't get on the boat and realize that I was missing something I really needed.
The best laid plans... While there are some stores on the ship, it's definitely not easy to find everything you need. Example, I somehow forgot pool flip flops. I had sneakers and lots of dressy sandals. I wanted a cheap plastic kind of pair. None to be found. Ooops.
Luckily, I did much better with dinner/evening outfits. I was pretty happy with the variety I managed and felt like I fit in pretty well. I had all the pieces I needed: clothing, accessories, jewelry.
So, in order to help others who might be in the same boat (punny?), below are pics of what I wore for dinners on our cruise. Most of the pieces were from Stitch Fix; I'd asked for my last couple of fixes to be for this trip. All of the pieces were things that I knew wouldn't wrinkle much: jersey, stretch materials, jeans. This was key because our ship had no public laundry room w/ irons.
Night 1 - Pretty casual with a pair of stretch trousers and a printed henley shirt.
Both pieces from Stitch Fix.
Night 2 - First full day at sea, printed shirts and white jeans.
Shirt from Marshall's and jeans from Stitch Fix.
Night 3 - Cozumel port day, stretch trousers and a button down shirt.
Pants from Stitch Fix and Portofino shirt from Express.
Night 4 - Thanksgiving, Formal Night, print dress and shawl.
Dress from Stitch Fix, shawl from Amazon (I think).
Night 5 - Key West port day, same pants from Night 1 and a print shirt.
Both pieces from Stitch Fix.